The short answer
If there’s no water at all, wet wipes are the way to go. If you have even a water bottle, a pre-soaped washcloth gives you a real wash, with lather and a rinse.
How they work
Wet wipes come damp in a sealed pack. They’re designed for quick wiping, and there’s nothing to rinse.
Pre-soaped washcloths like Messy Nessie come dry and compressed. Add water and they open into a full-size 9.5 × 12 in washcloth, ready to lather, wash, and rinse like a regular washcloth.
Side by side
| Pre-soaped washcloth | Wet wipes | |
|---|---|---|
| Stored | Dry, individually wrapped | Damp, in a pack |
| Needs water | Yes, a little | No |
| Soap and lather | Yes | Usually no |
| Rinse step | Yes | No |
| Size in use | Full washcloth | Wipe-sized |
| Size in your bag | Pocket-sized | A pack |
| Best for | Washing up, full-body clean-ups | Quick wipes with no water |
When wet wipes make sense
- There’s no water available.
- You only need to wipe your hands or a surface.
- Diaper changes and small spills.
When a pre-soaped washcloth is better
- You’re properly dirty or sweaty, after camping, sports, or a long day outside.
- You want to actually wash, with soap and a rinse.
- You want one thing that works in the shower and away from it.
- You want something that can sit in your car or gym bag without drying out.
- You’re staying somewhere that doesn’t provide washcloths.
Why not both?
Lots of people carry both: wipes for quick touch-ups and a few washcloths for when they really need to get clean. If you can only bring one and you’ll have some water, the washcloth does more.
Learn more about how pre-soaped washcloths work, or see how people use them for camping, travel, and sports.